National Retirement Planning Experts

National Coverage
Local Professionals

Home  > Financial Articles  > Retirement  > Do I Need a Financial Advisor for my 401(k)?

Do I Need a Financial Advisor for my 401(k)?

article image

Whether or not you need a financial advisor for your 401(k) retirement plan can largely depend on the type and number of investments you have and your knowledge and experience with them. A 401(k) can offer multiple investment options like mutual funds, index funds, real estate funds, foreign funds, bond funds, etc. This may make finding the right mix for your financial goals and risk appetite a challenging task. A 401(k) is also governed by several rules concerning contributions, distributions, and taxability. 

A financial advisor can offer personalized advice on investment strategies and risk management for your 401(k). This article discusses the pros and cons of hiring a 401(k) financial advisor to help you make an informed decision.

What is a 401(k) and how can an advisor help you manage it?

A 401(k) is a company-sponsored plan that is primarily designed to help employees save for their retirement. It offers a number of benefits like tax advantages, multiple investment options, an employer match, etc. It also provides the opportunity to roll over to a new 401(k) or an Individual Retirement Account (IRA) when you switch jobs. There are two types of 401(k)s – Traditional and Roth. They differ on the basis of taxability. A Traditional 401(k) offers tax-deductible contributions but taxes your withdrawals in retirement. On the other hand, a Roth 401(k) offers non-tax deductible contributions, but the distributions are tax-free in retirement. A Traditional 401(k) also has Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) that require you to withdraw your funds from the age of 73 as of 2023. 

If you feel confident in your ability to remember these rules and several others, stay updated with amendments to these rules, make investment decisions, and regularly review and adjust your portfolio, you may not need a financial advisor. However, if you find the lack of time to monitor your account, Internal Revenue Service (IRS) updates, and other things, hiring a financial advisor can be helpful.  

If you are wondering whether a  financial advisor can help you manage your 401(k), it can help to go through the pros and cons of your decision.


Pros of hiring a financial advisor to help manage your 401(k) 

1. They can help allocate funds to ensure optimal portfolio diversification

A 401(k) retirement account may offer a minimum of three investment options. Typically, you can expect 8 to 12 choices, including mutual funds, company stocks, variable annuities, Guaranteed Investment Contracts (GICs), etc. In some cases, the plan may offer brokerage accounts, allowing you to choose from various stocks, bonds, etc., other than the ones provided by the 401(k) plan. 

A financial advisor can help you create a 401(k) portfolio that is diversified and aligned with your financial goals and risk tolerance. For example, most publicly-listed companies that provide 401(k) plans may offer company stocks. Employers often offer their company's stocks at a lower cost than the actual price to employees to get them to invest their money in the company. While stocks present the opportunity for high returns, they also carry high risk. Investing the majority of your money in stocks can increase portfolio risk and affect its diversification. A financial advisor can help you understand the pros and cons of investing in these stocks and suggest a suitable allocation percentage based on your investment budget. If your 401(k) offers a brokerage account, you may have access to an extensive comprehensive selection of stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and others. A financial advisor can help you monitor these efficiently, and buy and sell according to your goals, risk appetite and market conditions. They can also help you understand the taxability of your sales and purchases within the 401(k) account. For example, your investments within a 401(k) enjoy the same tax advantages as the 401(k). This means you will not owe any capital gains tax on the earnings made through the purchase or sale of stocks within the 401(k). However, you would incur transaction costs and commissions on your trades. There may be several similar rules and tax treatments that you may not be aware of but the financial advisor would.

2. They can help you understand the 401(k) contribution limits, distribution rules, and tax advantages and liabilities

A 401(k) is a tax-advantaged account, but the kind of tax benefits you receive depends on the type of 401(k) you choose. A Traditional 401(k) may be more suitable if you foresee being in a lower tax bracket in retirement than now, while a Roth 401(k) may be ideal if you rather pay all your taxes now and enjoy tax-free retirement. A financial advisor can help you understand these rules and how they impact you so you can make a choice between the two. 

Another essential thing to know about the 401(k) is its contribution limit. As of 2023, you can contribute up to $22,500 if you are younger than 50 and $30,000 if you are 50 or older. You can contribute up to these limits to maximize your returns and tax benefits.  

It is important to be mindful of all 401(k) rules, to avoid penalties and unwanted taxes:

  • You must withdraw your funds before the age of 59.5 to avoid a 10% penalty and applicable taxes as per your tax slab.
  • You must make the first RMD at the age of 73 (as of 2023) in the case of a Traditional 401(k) account. If not, you will incur a 25% penalty for the amount not withdrawn (previously 50%). 
  • Your 401(k) account must be active and open for at least five years prior to your first withdrawal.

A financial advisor can help you understand 401(k) penalties and taxes, the process of account rollovers, tax dues when you roll over your account, etc., to keep you informed at all times. 

3. They can assist you with comprehensive financial planning in addition to your 401(k)

Hiring a financial advisor to manage your 401(k) can help you with comprehensive financial planning. You may have several other investments other than a 401(k) account. The professional can recommend asset allocation strategies keeping in mind your complete investment portfolio. They can ensure your risk appetite is maintained and your portfolio, both within a 401(k) and outside it, is well-diversified. The financial advisor can ensure there is no overlapping of investments. For instance, if you work in a domestic tech company and have invested in your company's stocks in the 401(k), they can recommend stocks from other industries and geographies outside of the 401(k). Similarly, if your portfolio is invested in aggressive growth-oriented investments, the financial advisor may recommend relatively conservative options for your 401(k). This will ensure that your overall risk and return ratio is balanced. Comprehensive financial planning in this regard can also help with tax diversification.   


Need a financial advisor? Compare vetted advisors matched to your specific requirements.

Choosing the right financial advisor is daunting, especially when there are thousands of financial advisors near you. We make it easy by matching you to vetted advisors that meet your unique needs. Matched advisors are all registered with FINRA/SEC. Click to compare vetted advisors now.


Cons of hiring a financial advisor to help manage your 401(k)

1. You may face a conflict of interest

Some financial advisors may have a conflict of interest when advising you on your 401(k) investments. For example, they may recommend investments that benefit them financially, such as funds that pay them a commission. Some financial advisors may also have a one-size-fits-all approach to investing that does not take into account your individual goals, risk tolerance, and financial situation. Make sure your financial advisor understands your needs and tailors their advice accordingly.

You must also understand how your financial advisor is compensated and whether they have any conflicts of interest. Additionally, it is important to be clear about your financial goals to avoid following the financial advisor's advice blindly.  

2. You may have to pay a higher fee

Hiring the best retirement financial advisors comes with a cost. Since the financial advisor will not be paid by the 401(k) plan itself, they will likely charge a flat fee or a percentage of Assets Under Management (AUM). Make sure you understand how your advisor is compensated and what the total cost will be. If you have a financial advisor for your other investments, you can consider hiring them for the 401(k) and adjusting the costs as an additional service. This can help you understand the fee structure better and avoid overpaying. 

3. Limited investment options may limit the financial advisor's role

A 401(k) may offer limited investment options. The fewer the options, the less scope for the financial advisor to recommend strategies and create a well-diversified portfolio. Some people may find that they are not getting the actual value for their money, considering the restricted role of the professional. But this is a decision only you can make based on your financial needs and the kinds of investments your 401(k) provides. If you think you can manage on your own, you can eliminate the extra costs of hiring a professional. However, if you lack the knowledge and experience, hiring a financial advisor can be worth your time and money. 

Questions to ask a financial advisor before hiring them

If you decide to hire a financial advisor to manage your 401(k), here are some questions you must ask them:

  1. What are the fees associated with your services, and how do you plan to charge me? 
  2. How often are you willing to communicate?
  3. Can you share your credentials and qualifications?
  4. How can I invest in the various investment options available in my plan? 
  5. What are the latest contribution limits for my 401(k)? 
  6. When can I withdraw my money from a 401(k)? 
  7. Can you recommend a 401(k) investment strategy that suits my goals and risk tolerance? 
  8. Will you look at my 401(k) plan and other investments cumulatively? 
  9. Are 401(k)s worth it, or should I look at other investment options? What are these alternatives based on my age, income, and financial goals? 
  10. How often should I review my 401(k) investments?
  11. How can you ensure transparency in your investment advice?
  12. Do you have experience in managing a 401(k) retirement account?
  13. How close am I to my retirement goal?
  14. What factors should I consider when altering my 401(k) strategies?
  15. Should I roll over my 401(k) to the new employer or carry it with the same employer when switching jobs? 
  16. What tax implications should I be aware of when making contributions and withdrawals from my 401(k) plan? 
  17. Are my 401(k) investments inflation-proof or resistant? If not, what can I do to strengthen my assets in the face of inflation? 
  18. Are there any investment restrictions or limitations within my 401(k) plan, and if so, what are they?
  19. How can I ensure that my 401(k) investments align with my overall financial goals and objectives?
  20. Can I take a loan against my 401(k)? If yes, what are the consequences of taking out a loan? 
  21. Can I make an early withdrawal from my 401(k) account? If yes, what are the consequences of my decision?
  22. Can you explain the role of diversification in my 401(k) portfolio and recommend ways to diversify my investments?
  23. How can I track the performance of my 401(k) investments, and what benchmarks should I use to evaluate their success?

To conclude

Ultimately, whether or not you need a financial advisor for your 401(k) depends on your individual needs and circumstances. While some people may benefit from the expertise and guidance of a professional, others may prefer to manage their investments themselves. It is crucial to consider factors such as your investment knowledge, risk tolerance, time horizon, and financial goals when making your decision. If you do decide to hire a financial advisor to manage your 401(k), make sure to carefully evaluate their qualifications, fees, and potential conflicts of interest before entrusting them with your retirement savings. Alternatively, you may consider taking an active role in managing your 401(k) to ensure that you are on track to meet your long-term financial objectives.

Use the free advisor match service to find a financial advisor in your area who meets your preference and requirements. The tool matches you with suitable professionals on the basis of a few simple questions. Answer a few simple questions based on your financial needs, and the match tool will help connect you with 1-3 financial advisors that are best suited to help you.

Search for articles

Find an Advisor
It's Fast, Free & Easy

  Your Information is Safe and Secure


The blog articles on this website are provided for general educational and informational purposes only, and no content included is intended to be used as financial or legal advice.
A professional financial advisor should be consulted prior to making any investment decisions. Each person's financial situation is unique, and your advisor would be able to provide you with the financial information and advice related to your financial situation.