Why Speculation May Be a Risky Investment Strategy

When choosing an investment strategy, one of the most critical factors to consider is the level of risk involved. The risk you take on must align with your risk tolerance and long-term financial goals. While speculation brings the expectation of substantial returns, it also comes with a significant level of risk and uncertainty. Therefore, it is important to understand what speculation truly involves and whether it suits your risk profile before diving into speculative investments.

A financial advisor can help you understand speculation in investment and the risks involved in it. This article will also talk in-depth about speculation in investment, explore its potential rewards, and, more importantly, shed light on the risks it carries.

What is speculation in investment, and why is it risky?

Speculation in investment refers to the practice of putting money into high-risk financial instruments with the expectation of earning a substantial return. Unlike traditional investing, where you make decisions based on fundamental aspects, such as a company’s financial health, corporate decisions, market capitalization, etc., speculation is more focused on predicting market movements. Speculators make educated guesses about future price changes and aim to profit from short-term fluctuations in the market. In speculative investment, the risk is significantly higher, and the potential for loss is also substantial. While speculators aim to make informed decisions based on market trends, the strategy is still inherently risky and can lead to losses if not employed with prudence. Speculation thrives on speed, and speculators often buy and sell assets quickly to capitalize on short-term price changes. They typically do not intend to hold onto their investments for long periods and move in and out of positions frequently to seize available market opportunities.

The goal of speculation is to achieve unusually high returns by making bold bets that, if successful, can yield substantial profits. However, speculators can suffer considerable losses if the market moves against them. Speculation is often compared to gambling because of the high risk involved. Much like gambling, speculators also have to make quick, timely, and risky moves. However, unlike gambling, speculation involves calculated moves and is not driven by pure luck.

One of the most common forms of speculation involves stocks. Speculators may invest in volatile stocks by making quick buy or sell decisions in response to short-term price movements. Unlike traditional investing, which focuses on the long-term growth potential of a stock, speculation in stocks works in the short term. Speculation also occurs in the bond market, particularly with high-risk bonds. These bonds have lower credit ratings and are considered riskier. Speculators buy these bonds because they potentially offer higher returns, but they also carry a substantial risk of default, which could lead to high losses. Cryptocurrencies are also highly speculative assets. They are prone to extreme price volatility. The real estate market also witnesses high risk with speculation. Speculators may buy a property in a developing area, anticipating that property values will rise as the area becomes more popular. Once the value increases, they sell the property for a profit. However, if the property does not escalate in value as speculated, the investor stands to incur a massive loss. Precious metals, such as gold, silver, and copper, are also speculative investments with fluctuating prices.

Speculators use various strategies, such as:

• Futures contracts: In this type of trade, two parties - the buyer and the seller, agree to buy or sell a specific asset at a set price on a future date. The buyer commits to purchasing the asset when the contract ends. Futures contracts are often used to trade commodities like gold, oil, etc., which are traded on exchanges.
• Put and call options: A put option gives the contract holder the right, but not the obligation, to sell a security at a specific price within a certain time frame. A call option, on the other hand, allows the holder to buy the underlying security at a fixed price before the contract expires. These options are used to speculate on the direction of a security's price.
• Short selling: This involves betting that the price of a security will go down. The trader borrows the security, sells it, and hopes to purchase it back later at a lower price in the future. The difference in the price results in a profit for the trader.

 

Risks in speculation

Speculation, while potentially lucrative, carries significant risks. This risk can vary depending on the type of investment instrument involved. Here’s a detailed look at the risks associated with different speculative investments:

• Stocks: Stock prices can fluctuate significantly over the short term due to a variety of factors, including economic and political events, investor sentiment, supply and demand, etc. Speculation in the stock market leads to high volatility and this volatility can lead to substantial market uncertainty. When prices begin to fall, speculators may panic. As a result, they start selling their stock holdings. This widespread panic selling leads to further price declines and creates a vicious cycle that further affects the stock market. While speculation can enhance market liquidity by increasing the number of buyers and sellers, it also contributes to market instability. High liquidity is crucial for the smooth operation of the market. However, the increased trading volume also contributes to price swings and hence adds more risk.
• Bonds: Bonds can be risky as there exists the risk of default, which can lead to significant losses. Bond prices are also impacted by fluctuations in interest rates, which can impact your returns. When interest rates are increased, bond prices generally fall, which can negatively impact speculative bond investments.
• Commodities: Speculation in commodity markets also carries significant risks. Like stocks, commodities can experience substantial price volatility. Speculators often buy commodities when prices are low and sell them when prices are high with an aim to profit from these fluctuations. While this does increase market liquidity, it can also lead to erratic price movements. Commodity markets are also influenced by various external factors, including weather conditions and changes in supply and demand dynamics. These factors can cause prices to fluctuate unpredictably and pose higher risks with the possibility of sudden profit and losses.
• Real estate: In real estate speculation, speculators buy properties and expect them to increase in value in the future. These properties are usually found in emerging and upcoming neighborhoods with the possibility of a surge in property value. Here, the focus is not on earning rental income but on the property values to drive up in a relatively short span. While this strategy can lead to high profits if property values rise in the expected timeframe, it also involves significant risks. Real estate markets can be unpredictable, and speculative investments may suffer if the concerned neighborhood does not develop similarly as anticipated.
• Currencies: Currency speculation involves buying and selling currencies based on predictions about their future value. This type of speculation is prevalent in the foreign exchange (Forex) market, where traders engage in transactions based on their beliefs about whether a currency is undervalued or overvalued. Currency prices are impacted by a range of factors, including interest rates, trade relationships, and geopolitical events, among others. The risk in currency speculation lies in the potential for rapid and unpredictable changes in exchange rates. If the market moves as anticipated, speculators can earn a profit. Conversely, if the market moves against the trader’s position, the losses can be substantial.
• Cryptocurrency: Cryptocurrencies are known for unpredictable price changes. While these digital currencies carry the potential for significant gains, the risks are equally high. The cryptocurrency market is relatively new and less regulated than the stock, bond, commodity, real estate and currency markets. This can lead to high volatility. There is also a lack of historical data on which speculations can be based. As a result, speculators may face substantial losses if they are not able to take calculated risks and market trends move against them.

 

SPONSORED WISERADVISOR

Other questions related to speculation investment

1. Investment vs speculation – what is the difference?

There is often confusion between investing and speculation. Both approaches aim to generate returns, but they do so with differing levels of risk and strategies. Here are some differences between the two:

• Risk tolerance: Investors have a relatively lower risk appetite than speculators. While the amount of risk can also be high in investing, especially in the case of equity and other high-risk assets, it is still comparatively lower than speculation. Moreover, you can use strategies like diversification and long-term investing to mitigate this risk. In speculation, you have to take on a considerably higher level of risk in the pursuit of potentially abnormally high returns.
• Investment horizon: Investing is typically associated with a long-term horizon. In most cases, investors purchase assets with the intention of holding them for years or even decades to benefit from long-term compounding. Investing follows the principle of buy and hold, which helps investors ride out short-term market volatility. On the other hand, speculation is often focused on short-term gains. It capitalizes on prevailing market opportunities and price fluctuations to earn high returns in the short term.
• Expected returns: Investors generally seek steady returns earned over time. In contrast, speculators aim for high returns. However, the potential for large profits is also matched by the potential for substantial losses.

 

2. Which is better – investing or speculating?

The choice between investing and speculating largely depends on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and level of experience. Investing is generally the better option if you want to build wealth gradually and achieve financial stability in the long run. It provides a more predictable approach to achieving steady returns and aligns with long-term financial planning. However, if you are experienced, have a high tolerance for risk, and are interested in seeking substantial short-term gains, speculation can be a better choice. Having said that, you must keep in mind that while the potential for high returns exists in speculation, the risk of losing your entire investment is also significant.

For average investors aiming for steady returns and long-term growth, investing in well-established companies with strong fundamentals is generally more beneficial than speculation. Speculation may offer high rewards but comes with greater risks and requires a more nuanced, sophisticated approach.

To conclude

Speculative investments come with high risks, so it is important to be cautious. Make sure to start slowly and gain experience before committing significant amounts of money. Using dummy accounts and educating yourself can help you understand the risks and rewards better. You can also consult a financial advisor for guidance on speculation strategies. This can help you gain a professional perspective.

Use the free advisor match tool to get matched with experienced financial advisors who can help you understand speculation in investment and the ensuing risks involved in it. Answer a few simple questions based on your financial needs and get matched with 2 to 3 financial advisors who are best suited to help you.